|
Post by Deathsong on Oct 14, 2015 18:51:57 GMT
So what are we allowed to say? Anything we want?
|
|
|
Post by Blemnot on Oct 14, 2015 19:46:49 GMT
What you can do - Anything that won't incriminate someone, like shitposting - You may ask questions to alive players to continue discussion.
What you cannot say - What you did for night action. - Who is Mafia or not
For example, Semprini cannot say Whyte is independent because that would confirm him as town.
If there's anything else you would like to say, feel free to ask.
|
|
|
Post by herecomesthechief on Oct 14, 2015 20:29:00 GMT
Back to the graveyard it is with you Moogle.
...The Final Day. I don't know how far we can go, but god dammit I'm not giving up when we're so close. LET'S DO THIS!
|
|
|
Post by Moogledrink on Oct 14, 2015 20:30:11 GMT
Hey guys I'm dead...again! Before I read through all 20 pages of this I want to just put who I think is town and who I think is mafia out of the 3 v 3. My job was when I was revived to try and get every roleclaim out so I could start as much discussion as possible because there was a lack of leaders on the town side when I died. Here ya go! I think Panther is Town - Nap dissapearing when it was Me vs Panther when I was trying to pinpoint Panther as mafia was very poor on Nap's part. Panther's defense was great and it's led me to believe he is actually town. I had to go against Panther because I needed to have his reasons as to why he went against me on Day 4, but he convinced me enough that I think he's town. Nap's played well by claiming the Amnesiac role because he alluded to that prior the role lists being given. But him disappearing leaving me to press Panther alone wasn't a good move. I think Blauze is Town - I went for Bittersteel in the thread because Blauze NEEDED to have a reaction, he's played far too nice and friendly so he needs to get some fire in him now to defend himself. I wanted to make the accusations because if Bittersteel was the one to do it Blauze would be crucified. Bittersteel is a very experienced player and he's been town read all game I feel. I never read Blauze as anything but he's been very consistent with his nice guy attitude. It's up to Blauze now to defend himself against Bittersteel and that's going to be hard. I think Joe is Town - Well I KNOW he's town, TheWorst confirmed he roleblocked Joe on the night he wanted to send a message and Joe was wondering why Blemnot didn't send it. Actor fakeclaim from Feanon was very good but I always suspected that the hidden role was the person sending the messages and Joe claiming it coupled with TheWorst roleblocking him last night fully confirmed Joe as town for me. With Joe 100% town it leaves Bitter vs Blauze and Nap vs Panther to decide who wins the game. We only need 1 correct out of the two. Oh and Gief was utter scum in this game and I don't want to hear anything about me getting starting the lynch train on him when he was the most scummiest town that ever lived! (If any of the more experience players of Mafia can tell me how I've done this game that'd be great, it was my first ever mafia game so I know I've probably goofed a lot haha! Also I'm a nice person and playing like an agressive asshole detective with towns best interest at heart was REALLY REALLY HARD! )
|
|
|
Post by Deathsong on Oct 14, 2015 21:54:58 GMT
You started discussion and that is precisely what you need to do to play this game good. You had a tenadacy to get too hot headed and tunnel vision on someone though. You need to keep more of an open mind, or else someone will get your hot head outta there.
|
|
|
Post by Fusion on Oct 14, 2015 22:46:44 GMT
I'd agree you're very aggressive and prone to talking which is great. But you're aggressive in a way they can control you. If it was Panther vs Feanon they would have controlled your hot headed ness to a guaranteed loss for town.
|
|
|
Post by Blemnot on Oct 14, 2015 23:21:47 GMT
This game will boil down to Whytepanther vs Nap. I'm sure other two will result in 1-1.
and I remember you guys saying "if town lynches Whytepanther, they don't deserve to win"
|
|
|
Post by Karthulu on Oct 14, 2015 23:36:02 GMT
If they lynch Panther just say "FUCK THIS" and then end the game. Like, a nuke, or something.
|
|
|
Post by Prozzach on Oct 14, 2015 23:49:41 GMT
I think Joe accidentally proved Feanon is the mafia through cheating, all because of yaoi fanfics
|
|
|
Post by Deathsong on Oct 14, 2015 23:58:14 GMT
Seriously, if they lynch Panther over "I chose bodyguard over doctor" NAP then I don't even fucking know man. Besides, it's not like Feanon wasn't already proven to be mafia.
|
|
|
Post by Blemnot on Oct 15, 2015 0:20:15 GMT
I'm starting to regret letting you guys post in the thread.
|
|
|
Post by Moogledrink on Oct 15, 2015 0:36:42 GMT
Haha all of this on Page 18 about me! Looks like I was commanding all the attention in the deadboard too haha! (When I see the mafia board at the end of the game I assume it's all of them going "Just watch Moogle kill all the town members because none of them except Panther are challenging her views at all!"
RudeSemprini: It's amazing, because I saw her leading the charge against Gief and figured "Wow, her head is really in the game. She must really know what she's doing." Nope. She's bullshitting just as much as the rest of us. She's just TERRIFYINGLY confident in herself. She's 100% certain Panther is scum, and everything in her eyes is further proof of it.
HereComesTheChief: I agree, it's...actually kinda scary how confident she is.
CaptainRodriguez: Moogle is usually so friendly that it's really fucking weird to see her posts in the mafia game.
Belmint: She reminds me of me when I take tests in school. I run in screaming, and chances are that I'll probably leave dead. Also, MVP awards should be going out to her and BringBack, hands down.
Karthulu: In what world would Panther be scum if he claimed the role AND character BEFORE Nap, who claimed the EXACT SAME pairing? Blauze/Bitter are a different case, but jesus christ. She's not listening to anyone. Her entire argument for Panther is that he voted for her once. Super OMGUS. SOMEONE ELSE SPEAK UP. Moogle is commanding this discussion by no selling every argument someone else says.
Belmint: That's the problem with this town and also the reason that Moogle is my favorite player; every single member of this town has been so submissive in their posting and accusations it hurts. It made the early, more aggressive players very apparent early in the game, and now Moogle is the only person actually willing to stir up discussion. Everyone is afraid except her for some reason. Quite frankly, I can't wait until the next game because I want to play again, and I want to butt heads with her. It seems like a lot of fun, and I also want to see it happen because the only people who have actually stood to her are WhytePanther and... that's about it.
You guys are right. All of the guys I'd assume to play aggressive died early so we were left with a lot of quiet and safe town players and it was up to me, a freaking newbie with no idea who to play, to attempt to be loud and in charge otherwise the game would be a boring snoozefest. I'm reading all of this and I can't decide if you guys want to kill me for being utterly stubborn and argumentive and by going on rampages against the wrong people or hug me for making the game interesting and forcing the game to go into this 3 v 3 situation now, hahaha! :')
|
|
|
Post by Gief on Oct 15, 2015 2:26:31 GMT
Hey guys I'm dead...again! Before I read through all 20 pages of this I want to just put who I think is town and who I think is mafia out of the 3 v 3. My job was when I was revived to try and get every roleclaim out so I could start as much discussion as possible because there was a lack of leaders on the town side when I died. Here ya go! I think Panther is Town - Nap dissapearing when it was Me vs Panther when I was trying to pinpoint Panther as mafia was very poor on Nap's part. Panther's defense was great and it's led me to believe he is actually town. I had to go against Panther because I needed to have his reasons as to why he went against me on Day 4, but he convinced me enough that I think he's town. Nap's played well by claiming the Amnesiac role because he alluded to that prior the role lists being given. But him disappearing leaving me to press Panther alone wasn't a good move. I think Blauze is Town - I went for Bittersteel in the thread because Blauze NEEDED to have a reaction, he's played far too nice and friendly so he needs to get some fire in him now to defend himself. I wanted to make the accusations because if Bittersteel was the one to do it Blauze would be crucified. Bittersteel is a very experienced player and he's been town read all game I feel. I never read Blauze as anything but he's been very consistent with his nice guy attitude. It's up to Blauze now to defend himself against Bittersteel and that's going to be hard. I think Joe is Town - Well I KNOW he's town, TheWorst confirmed he roleblocked Joe on the night he wanted to send a message and Joe was wondering why Blemnot didn't send it. Actor fakeclaim from Feanon was very good but I always suspected that the hidden role was the person sending the messages and Joe claiming it coupled with TheWorst roleblocking him last night fully confirmed Joe as town for me. With Joe 100% town it leaves Bitter vs Blauze and Nap vs Panther to decide who wins the game. We only need 1 correct out of the two. Oh and Gief was utter scum in this game and I don't want to hear anything about me getting starting the lynch train on him when he was the most scummiest town that ever lived! (If any of the more experience players of Mafia can tell me how I've done this game that'd be great, it was my first ever mafia game so I know I've probably goofed a lot haha! Also I'm a nice person and playing like an agressive asshole detective with towns best interest at heart was REALLY REALLY HARD! ) But yeah, lesson learned I guess I actually hope I'm mafia or third party next game, maybe it suits me better trying to fuck with people
|
|
|
Post by BB1996 on Oct 15, 2015 5:15:18 GMT
This board is kinda redundant now ain't it?
|
|
|
Post by Blemnot on Oct 15, 2015 18:33:43 GMT
Worst was roleblocked last night.
|
|